Judge Elizabeth Scherer
| |

Broward Judge Elizabeth Scherer Was Assigned To Parkland School Shooter Case At Random

– Judge Elizabeth Scherer –

Before being appointed to the case of Parkland school shooter Nikolas Cruz, Broward Circuit Judge Elizabeth Scherer had never presided over a high-profile death penalty prosecution.

Judge Elizabeth Scherer

A computer program assigned her to the case at random. Disregarding her experience or the fact that no mass shooting of this magnitude had ever been tried in the United States.

Cruz’s penalty trial for the Feb. 14, 2018, killing of 14 students and three adults at Parkland’s Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School is officially started.

And every move Scherer makes is analyzed, at least in part, through the lens of how she was assigned and her inexperience. Especially in comparison to the case’s seasoned prosecutors and defense attorneys.

Overseeing the Cruz trial would be stressful even for the most battle-hardened jurist. Moreover, the major mistakes that hurt Cruz’s case could result in a death sentence being reversed on appeal.

That would almost certainly imply a retrial years from now, reopening the emotional wounds of the families and community.

Last month, she discharged 11 possible jurors before allowing the lawyers to interrogate them.

Cruz’s Brain was Damaged

Scherer also expressed dissatisfaction with the length of an impending hearing to determine if defense specialists can testify that Cruz’s brain was damaged as a result of his birth mother’s alcoholism.

The judge predicted it would take a day or two, but the attorneys, who seemed frustrated, estimated it would take a week.

“The Cruz case demonstrates what occurs when an inexperienced judge handles a high-profile death sentence case,” said Bob Jarvis. He is a law professor at Nova Southeastern University.

However, both the main attorney and co-counsel must have prior experience in criminal law and trial, as well as knowledge of capital case processes.

Melisa McNeill was appointed to manage Cruz’s staff by Finkelstein, who is also leaving office in 2021. McNeill has been an assistant public defender for almost two decades. However, he has represented 17 murder suspects at trial, including two death sentence cases.

See Also:

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How Old is Elizabeth Scherer?

46 years

2.  What is your Birthday of Elizabeth?

4 Jun

3. What is her Zodiac Sign?

Her zodiac sign is Gemini

4. How Tall is Elizabeth?

She is 5 feet 6inches tall

5. Is she Married?

No, she is divorced

6. Where is Elizabeth from?


7. What is their Net Worth of Elizabeth?


8. Does she have Children?

She has only one child

9. Does Elizabeth have Siblings?

Yes, she has two brothers

10. What does Elizabeth do to Earn a Living?

Judge, Florida Circuit Court Judge

According to David Weinstein, a Miami criminal defense attorney, and former prosecutor. Both sides should utilize their considerable skills to educate Scherer rather than exploit her.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.